Rentals
Renting on Staten Island
Available now
Current rentals
Filter by price, bedrooms, bathrooms and neighborhood on the full search.
No rentals listed at the moment
Rental inventory turns over quickly. Tell us what you are looking for and we will call you the moment something suitable comes in.
If you are renting
How we help renters
We take rentals seriously
Plenty of agencies treat rentals as an afterthought. We do not — a renter this year is often a buyer in three, and either way you deserve someone who picks up the phone.
We know what is actually available
Rental inventory moves fast and much of it never gets properly advertised. We hear about units through the office and through landlords we have worked with for years.
We prepare you to be chosen
Good units get multiple applications. We will tell you what a landlord here wants to see so your application is the easy one to say yes to.
If you are a landlord
How we help owners
Qualified tenants, properly screened
Marketing your unit is the easy part. Finding a tenant who pays on time and looks after the place is the part that matters.
Priced for the actual market
A month vacant costs more than pricing correctly from the start. We will tell you what your unit will genuinely rent for.
Paperwork handled
Applications, leases and the disclosures New York requires — done properly, so there are no problems later.
From renters and landlords
In their words
I’ve tried listing my apartment with other agencies and I have been through everything from (no one interested) to (undesirable potential tenants). I was giving up hope and was going to let my apartment remain vacant. … Not only did she find me amazing tenants (that I hope never move), but my apartment was listed for 1 day!!! Yes 1 day! and I had qualified wonderful people renting within 2 days time. This agency really has the most top notch Agents I have ever had the pleasure of working with!
Every other agency I contacted basically did everything shy of just hanging up on me. It’s hard enough finding affordable housing and a decent apartment in a good area. Most other agencies can’t seem to be bothered with “rentals”. But then I called M. Donato and was surprised at how friendly their staff was. They promised I would be contacted by an Agent that day. Within less than 30 mins, not only was I called back, but the Agent already had 3 apartments for me to look at!